Reach for the Stars: Side by Side

My quilt Catch a Falling Star, based on Minnesota quiltmaker Terri Krysan’s Reach for the Stars quilt, is currently hanging in the Pine Needle Quilt Shop where it is receiving very nice comments from customers.

Several people have asked how my quilt differs from Terri Krysan’s (other than the obvious difference of fabric choices) so I thought I would give you a look at both quilts side by side:

Reach for the Stars3
Left, Terri Krysan’s original quilt “Reach for the Stars” (86¾” x 106½”), 2012. Right, Dawn’s version, “Catch a Falling Star” (84″ x 105″), 2015.

(Photo on left copyright Quilter’s Newsletter. Used with permission. Photo by Melissa Karlin Mahoney. Photo on right by Bill Volckening.)

The center medallion and three of the blocks were made following Terri’s design. From there I departed in ways both large and small. I’ll use the quilt outline below to explain those differences:medallion quilt layout

Blocks 1 and 2: no changes.

Block 3: incorporated fussy-cut images in outer part of block.

Block 4: changed center of block to a fussy-cut image enclosed in an inset circle. Moved to Block 11 position.

Block 5: no change.

Block 6: replaced pinwheel in center of block with a 4-Patch Wonder block. Moved to Block 7 position.

Block 7: eliminated appliquéd circles, incorporated fussy-cut image in center of block. Moved to Block 14 position.

Block 8: incorporated fussy-cut image in center of block and changed design of outer part to incorporate fussy-cut border stripe. Moved to Block 6 position.

Block 9: added four triangles to create a star. Moved to Block 13 position.

Block 10: replaced block completely with design spotted on a coffee mug.

Block 11: replaced block completely with a block I dreamed up (although it may well exist elsewhere). Moved to Block 4 position.

Block 12: made the center a square within a square and changed the color value in the corner four-patches to avoid having dark fabric in the points where they would bleed into the black sashing. Moved to Block 9 position.

Block 13: incorporated fussy-cut image into circle in center. My circle is inset rather than appliquéd. Moved to Block 8 position.

Block 14: replaced center of block with a double pinwheel block incorporating fussy-cut images. Moved to Block 12 position.

That’s it for the blocks, though I should note that Terri used fussy-cut images in seven of her 14 blocks. I challenged myself to incorporate fussy-cut images in all 14.

The setting triangles were made following Terri’s design but I altered the design of the checked border to make all four corners symmetrical. I’m very proud of that achievement.

Now you probably think all 14 blocks are different, don’t you? Not so! Two of the blocks are exactly the same design. They just look different because of the fabrics used. Can you spot which two are the same? Here’s a bigger photo of my quilt to help you look:

CAFS front BV photo 800Happy hunting!

 

 

 

This entry was posted in 4-Patch Wonder, Reach for the Stars sampler quilt, update. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Reach for the Stars: Side by Side

  1. Charlie says:

    Congratulations on a startingly beautiful quilt. The squares around the edge set it off so well. It’s a real winner.

  2. Rebecca says:

    Absolutely stunning. I am going to guess 3 and 12. But it took a lot of hunting and I may still be incorrect! This and Olivia Twist are two of my favorites. The fussy cutting is spectacular especially Block 5. As Charlie said above, you truly do have a real winner.

  3. Gail says:

    Wow! I love the colors you chose – it’s neat to see side by side with the original pattern. What an intricate quilt –

  4. Jeanne says:

    Thanks for the detailed explanation and chance to compare.
    Beautiful! Good choices.

  5. Wendy says:

    Hello! Love this quilt, and was wondering if there is anywhere to get the pattern since the old issues it was in are no longer available in print.

    • Dawn says:

      Wendy, the issues are still available on Quilter’s Newsletter Magazine’s website, quiltersnewsletter.com. Most of the issues are available in print; a few are digital only. A friend of mine found the issues she needed at her local library: seven issues in all, beginning with Oct./Nov. 2013 and ending with Oct./Nov. 2014.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *